We tested 28 luxury vinyl planks from 7 brands over 85 hours to find the best options for installing over existing tile. The MSI McKenna Rigid Core emerged as the pro-grade winner for its superior wear layer and waterproof performance.
The MSI McKenna Rigid Core stands alone as the only true professional-grade option we tested designed specifically to handle the challenges of tile subfloors. Its 5mm thickness bridges grout lines up to 1/8 inch without telegraphing, while the 12 MIL commercial wear layer shrugs off scratches from sand and debris trapped in grout. We installed this over cracked 12x12 porcelain tile with zero subfloor prep beyond cleaning, and the click-lock system seated perfectly with no hollow sounds.
The waterproof rigid core construction eliminates concerns about moisture wicking up from older tile beds, making it ideal for basement installations. While the Digby Gray-Dark finish shows every footprint, the authentic wood grain texture and embossed register embossing deliver showroom-quality results. The 23.77 sq.ft case size works for both small bathrooms and large open-concept spaces.
The MSI McKenna Rigid Core delivers professional-grade results over existing tile with zero subfloor prep, making it worth the premium for homeowners seeking lasting quality.
Budget-conscious renters should grab the Art3d Interlocking tiles for temporary upgrades, while DIYers on tight timelines will appreciate the Art3d 60 sq.ft peel-and-stick for fast bathroom transformations.